Three Strangers (1946)

Film and Plot Synopsis

On the Eve of Chinese New Year in 1938, Crystal Shackelford brings two men back to her London flat that she’s never met before. Legend has it that if three strangers make the same wish before the idol of Kwan Yin as the clock strikes midnight, the goddess will grant their wish. The three decide to split a sweepstakes ticket on a horse race if it wins. Once they make their wish, the three go their separate ways. We then learn that each one of them has much turmoil in their lives. Crystal is using every means possible to either woo back her estranged husband or make him suffer like she’s been suffering. The alcoholic Johnny West is on the lamb from the murder of a police officer, and Jerome K. Arbutny schemes to get back the trust money he embezzled from a naive widow before she finds out her money is gone. As the three stories play out, the looming sweepstakes nears. Who wins? Who loses? Only Kwan Yin knows for sure.

Buy the Film

Three Strangers

$9.99  in stock
12 new from $9.33
5 used from $9.31
Free shipping
as of December 8, 2023 11:09 am
*As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

‘Three Strangers’ Movie Summary

The summary below contains spoilers.
Three Strangers (1946)Three Strangers takes place on Chinese New Year in London 1938. Crystal Shackleford (Geraldine Fitzgerald) invites two random men to her flat with the belief that if three strangers make the same wish to an idol of Kwan Yin—the Chinese goddess of fortune and destiny—the goddess will grant that wish.

The men are a gruff solicitor named Jerome K. Arbutny (Sydney Greenstreet) and a charming erudite named Johnny West (Peter Lorre) who is quite the drunk.

Crystal figures that cold hard cash can make all their problems go away, so she convinces them to go in on a sweepstakes ticket for the Grand National horse race with her. If the sweepstakes picks their ticket, the three agree not to sell it until the race is over.

Shackleford wants to use her share to win back her estranged husband. Arbutny wants to use his to join a prestigious Barrister’s Club. Then there’s Johnny. He’s a simple drunk, and would just buy a bar to live in.

We soon find that each person has skeletons in their closet, and more than a few issues they are dealing with.

Crystal’s story

Crystal’s husband, David (Alan Napier), fell in love with Janet Elliott (Marjorie Riordan) before moving to Canada. However, he returns this same night—after Johnny and Arbutny leave. He demands a divorce, but Crystle still loves him, and refuses. She sabotages his chances at a promotion, and then lies to Janet that she’s pregnant with his child. She believes every word Crystal says, and returns home to Canada.

Johnny’s story

Meanwhile, Johnny finds himself on the lam for his participation in a botched robbery that resulted in the death of a police officer. A young woman named Icey Crane (Joan Lorring) adores Johnny, and helps hide him. She also provides the police an alibi for the heist’s ringleader—and actual murderer, Bertram Fallon (Robert Shayne).

Under questioning, Fallon confesses to the robbery, but he blames the actual murder on Johnny and one other man named Gabby (Peter Whitney). Eventually the police catch Johnny, and a court sentences him to death. However, Gabby’s able to find Fallon on his way to prison and then stabs him. As Fallon dies, he gives a deathbed confession clearing Johnny.

Arbutny’s story

Arbutny too finds himself in over his head. He’s been a big stock speculator using the money from the trust fund of Lady Rhea Belladon (Rosalind Ivan). She’s an eccentric widow of a man whom she believes she can talk to from the grave. Unfortunately for Arbutny, the stock plummets, resulting in a margin call.

Now desperate for money, Arbutny proposes marriage to Lady Belladon, but after she consults her dead husband, she turns him down. Additionally, the dead Lord Belladon wants her to have the books checked for accuracy. As Arbutny is about to shoot himself, spots a story in the newspaper that the sweepstakes ticket drew the favorite in the Grand National. Death can wait for now.

We’ve got a winner!

The three strangers excitedly head back to Crystal’s flat. Arbutny, needing money now, wants to sell his share of the ticket immediately before his theft is uncovered. While Johnny’s fine with that, Shackleford isn’t. She insists they stick to their original agreement. This angers Arbutny greatly, and in a fit, he grabs the statue of Kwan Yin, and kills her with it as the radio announces their horse won.

Johnny’s a drunk, but he’s no dummy. When he points out that the three signatures on the winning ticket would provide a credible motive for murder, he recommends they destroy the ticket.

Once they leave the flat, guilt overcomes Arbunty. He panics, and runs into a busy street where his antics stops traffic. As a policeman walks up to him, he confesses to the murder. Johnny quietly returns to the pub, where Icey soon finds him. She’s all a fella needs, so he sets the ticket on fire for a happily ever after.

Additional Film Information

Rate the Film!

Our Rating

Our Rating

Warner Bros. released Three Strangers on January 28, 1946. Jean Negulesco directed the film starring Peter Lorre, Sydney Greenstreet, and Geraldine Fitzgerald.

User Rating: Be the first one !
Show More
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Back to top button
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x